Whoopie pies are a favorite among children. They're delicious and sweet, two things that every kid loves. Plus, a traditional whoopie pie is chocolate, another thing that children adore. Finally, they're hand-sized. That means that even the smallest of children can enjoy one!
If you've ever been to Pennsylvania, chances are you've tried a traditional Pennsylvania Dutch whoopie pie. They're very common in this state, appearing in numerous stores and markets. Many spins on the traditional whoopie pie have come about in recent years.
Once you've made this whoopie pie recipe, feel free to try out other varieties of whoopie pie! Another common flavor is chocolate chip. Pumpkin whoopie pies often make an appearance in fall. Talk to your kids, and decide together what new whoopie pie flavors you want to make!
Pennsylvania Dutch Whoopie Pies are a hometown favorite, with chocolate being the original cake flavor. Our recipe for the chocolate cake confection filled with homemade vanilla cream filling tastes like they came fresh from the ovens at the Amish farmer’s market!
clock clock icon
cutlery cutlery icon
flag flag icon
folder folder icon
instagram instagram icon
pinterest pinterest icon
facebook facebook icon
print print icon
squares squares icon
heart heart icon
heart solid heart solid icon
Cookie
1 cup shortening
Filling
1 cup shortening
Cook Mode Prevent your screen from going dark
1. Preheat the oven to 400 degrees F. Grease cookie sheets.
2. In a large bowl, cream together 1 cup of shortening and white sugar until light and fluffy.
3. Beat in the eggs one at a time then stir in the vanilla and milk.
4. Combine the flour, cocoa and salt, stir into the creamed mixture.
5. Stir together the baking soda and hot water then add to the batter.
6. Drop by tablespoonfuls onto the prepared cookie sheet.
7. Bake for 8 minutes in the preheated oven, until firm but not over baked. Allow cookies to cool on baking sheets before removing to wire racks to cool completely.
8. To make the filling: In a medium bowl, cream together the shortening and butter with the confectioner’s sugar and 1/4 cup of flour until light and fluffy.
9. Gradually beat in the half and half and vanilla until well mixed. Sandwich some filling between the flat sides of two cookies to form each whoopie pie.
window.trCommon={"minRating":6,"ajaxurl":"https:\/\/www.momswhothink.com\/wp-admin\/admin-ajax.php","ratingNonce":"","postId":9625};
window.TastyRecipes = window.TastyRecipes || {}; window.TastyRecipes.smoothScroll = {
init() {
document.addEventListener( 'click', ( e ) => {
let anchor = e.target;
if ( anchor.tagName !== 'A' ) {
anchor = anchor.closest( 'a.tasty-recipes-scrollto' );
} if ( ! anchor || ! anchor.classList.contains( 'tasty-recipes-scrollto' ) ) {
return;
} const elementHref = anchor.getAttribute( 'href' );
if ( ! elementHref ) {
return;
} e.preventDefault();
this.goToSelector( elementHref );
});
},
goToSelector( selector ) {
const element = document.querySelector( selector );
if ( ! element ) {
return;
}
element.scrollIntoView( { behavior: 'smooth' } );
}
}; document.addEventListener(
'DOMContentLoaded',
() => window.TastyRecipes.smoothScroll.init()
); (function(){ var bothEquals = function( d1, d2, D ) {
var ret = 0;
if (d1<=D) {
ret++;
}
if (d2<=D) {
ret++;
}
return ret === 2;
}; var frac =function frac(x,D,mixed){var n1=Math.floor(x),d1=1;var n2=n1+1,d2=1;if(x!==n1){while(bothEquals(d1,d2,D)){var m=(n1+n2)/(d1+d2);if(x===m){if(d1+d2d2){d2=D+1;}else {d1=D+1;}break}else if(xD){d1=d2;n1=n2}if(!mixed){return[0,n1,d1];}var q=Math.floor(n1/d1);return[q,n1-q*d1,d1]};frac.cont=function cont(x,D,mixed){var sgn=x<0?-1:1;var B=x*sgn;var P_2=0,P_1=1,P=0;var Q_2=1,Q_1=0,Q=0;var A=Math.floor(B);while(Q_1<D){A=Math.floor(B);P=A*P_1+P_2;Q=A*Q_1+Q_2;if(B-AD){if(Q_1>D){Q=Q_2;P=P_2}else{Q=Q_1;P=P_1}}if(!mixed){return[0,sgn*P,Q];}var q=Math.floor(sgn*P/Q);return[q,sgn*P-q*Q,Q]}; window.tastyRecipesVulgarFractions = JSON.parse(decodeURIComponent("%7B%22%C2%BC%22%3A%221%2F4%22%2C%22%C2%BD%22%3A%221%2F2%22%2C%22%C2%BE%22%3A%223%2F4%22%2C%22%E2%85%93%22%3A%221%2F3%22%2C%22%E2%85%94%22%3A%222%2F3%22%2C%22%E2%85%95%22%3A%221%2F5%22%2C%22%E2%85%96%22%3A%222%2F5%22%2C%22%E2%85%97%22%3A%223%2F5%22%2C%22%E2%85%98%22%3A%224%2F5%22%2C%22%E2%85%99%22%3A%221%2F6%22%2C%22%E2%85%9A%22%3A%225%2F6%22%2C%22%E2%85%9B%22%3A%221%2F8%22%2C%22%E2%85%9C%22%3A%223%2F8%22%2C%22%E2%85%9D%22%3A%225%2F8%22%2C%22%E2%85%9E%22%3A%227%2F8%22%7D")); window.tastyRecipesFormatAmount = function(amount, el) {
if ( parseFloat( amount ) === parseInt( amount ) ) {
return amount;
}
var roundType = 'frac';
if (typeof el.dataset.amountShouldRound !== 'undefined') {
if ('false' !== el.dataset.amountShouldRound) {
if ( 'number' === el.dataset.amountShouldRound ) {
roundType = 'number';
} else if ('frac' === el.dataset.amountShouldRound) {
roundType = 'frac';
} else if ('vulgar' === el.dataset.amountShouldRound) {
roundType = 'vulgar';
} else {
roundType = 'integer';
}
}
}
if ('number' === roundType) {
amount = Number.parseFloat(amount).toPrecision(2);
} else if ('integer' === roundType) {
amount = Math.round(amount);
} else if ('frac' === roundType || 'vulgar' === roundType) {
var denom = 8;
if (typeof el.dataset.unit !== 'undefined') {
var unit = el.dataset.unit;
if (['cups','cup','c'].includes(unit)) {
denom = 4;
if (0.125 === amount) {
denom = 8;
}
if ("0.1667" === Number.parseFloat( amount ).toPrecision(4)) {
denom = 6;
}
}
if (['tablespoons','tablespoon','tbsp'].includes(unit)) {
denom = 2;
}
if (['teaspoons','teaspoon','tsp'].includes(unit)) {
denom = 8;
}
}
var amountArray = frac.cont( amount, denom, true );
var newAmount = '';
if ( amountArray[1] !== 0 ) {
newAmount = amountArray[1] + '/' + amountArray[2];
if ('vulgar' === roundType) {
Object.keys(window.tastyRecipesVulgarFractions).forEach(function(vulgar) {
if (newAmount === window.tastyRecipesVulgarFractions[vulgar]) {
newAmount = vulgar;
}
});
}
}
if ( newAmount ) {
newAmount = ' ' + newAmount;
}
if ( amountArray[0] ) {
newAmount = amountArray[0] + newAmount;
}
amount = newAmount;
}
return amount;
}; window.tastyRecipesUpdatePrintLink = () => { const printButton = document.querySelector( '.tasty-recipes-print-button' ); if ( ! printButton ) {
return;
} const printURL = new URL( printButton.href );
const searchParams = new URLSearchParams( printURL.search ); const unitButton = document.querySelector( '.tasty-recipes-convert-button-active' );
const scaleButton = document.querySelector( '.tasty-recipes-scale-button-active' ); let unit = '';
let scale = ''; if ( unitButton ) {
unit = unitButton.dataset.unitType;
searchParams.delete('unit');
searchParams.set( 'unit', unit );
} if ( scaleButton ) {
scale = scaleButton.dataset.amount;
searchParams.set( 'scale', scale );
} const paramString = searchParams.toString();
const newURL = '' === paramString ? printURL.href : printURL.origin + printURL.pathname + '?' + paramString;
const printLinks = document.querySelectorAll( '.tasty-recipes-print-link' ); printLinks.forEach( ( el ) => {
el.href = newURL;
}); const printButtons = document.querySelectorAll( '.tasty-recipes-print-button' );
printButtons.forEach( ( el ) => {
el.href = newURL;
});
}; document.addEventListener( 'DOMContentLoaded', () => { if ( ! window.location.href.includes( '/print/' ) ) {
return;
} const searchParams = new URLSearchParams( window.location.search ); const unit = searchParams.get( 'unit' );
const scale = searchParams.get( 'scale' ); if ( unit && ( 'metric' === unit || 'usc' === unit ) ) {
document.querySelector( '.tasty-recipes-convert-button[data-unit-type="' + unit + '"]' ).click();
} if ( scale && Number(scale) > 0 ) {
document.querySelector( '.tasty-recipes-scale-button[data-amount="' + Number(scale) + '"]' ).click();
}
});
}()); (function(){
var buttonClass = 'tasty-recipes-scale-button',
buttonActiveClass = 'tasty-recipes-scale-button-active',
buttons = document.querySelectorAll('.tasty-recipes-scale-button');
if ( ! buttons ) {
return;
} buttons.forEach(function(button){
button.addEventListener('click', function(event){
event.preventDefault();
var recipe = event.target.closest('.tasty-recipes');
if ( ! recipe ) {
return;
}
var otherButtons = recipe.querySelectorAll('.' + buttonClass);
otherButtons.forEach(function(bt){
bt.classList.remove(buttonActiveClass);
});
button.classList.add(buttonActiveClass); var scalables = recipe.querySelectorAll('span[data-amount]');
var buttonAmount = parseFloat( button.dataset.amount );
scalables.forEach(function(scalable){
if (typeof scalable.dataset.amountOriginalType === 'undefined'
&& typeof scalable.dataset.nfOriginal === 'undefined') {
if (-1 !== scalable.innerText.indexOf('/')) {
scalable.dataset.amountOriginalType = 'frac';
}
if (-1 !== scalable.innerText.indexOf('.')) {
scalable.dataset.amountOriginalType = 'number';
}
Object.keys(window.tastyRecipesVulgarFractions).forEach(function(vulgar) {
if (-1 !== scalable.innerText.indexOf(vulgar)) {
scalable.dataset.amountOriginalType = 'vulgar';
}
});
if (typeof scalable.dataset.amountOriginalType !== 'undefined') {
scalable.dataset.amountShouldRound = scalable.dataset.amountOriginalType;
}
}
var amount = parseFloat( scalable.dataset.amount ) * buttonAmount;
amount = window.tastyRecipesFormatAmount(amount, scalable);
if ( typeof scalable.dataset.unit !== 'undefined' ) {
if ( ! scalable.classList.contains('nutrifox-quantity') ) {
if ( ! scalable.classList.contains('nutrifox-second-quantity') ) {
amount += ' ' + scalable.dataset.unit;
}
}
}
scalable.innerText = amount;
}); var nonNumerics = recipe.querySelectorAll('[data-has-non-numeric-amount]');
nonNumerics.forEach(function(nonNumeric){
var indicator = nonNumeric.querySelector('span[data-non-numeric-label]');
if ( indicator ) {
nonNumeric.removeChild(indicator);
}
if ( 1 !== buttonAmount ) {
indicator = document.createElement('span');
indicator.setAttribute('data-non-numeric-label', true);
var text = document.createTextNode(' (x' + buttonAmount + ')');
indicator.appendChild(text);
nonNumeric.appendChild(indicator);
}
}); window.tastyRecipesUpdatePrintLink();
});
});
}()); window.TastyRecipes = window.TastyRecipes || {};
window.TastyRecipes.cookMode = {
wakeLockApi: false,
wakeLock: false,
cookModeSelector: '.tasty-recipes-cook-mode',
init() {
if ("wakeLock" in navigator && "request" in navigator.wakeLock) {
this.wakeLockApi = navigator.wakeLock;
} const cookModes = document.querySelectorAll(this.cookModeSelector); if (cookModes.length > 0) {
for (const cookMode of cookModes) {
if (this.wakeLockApi) {
cookMode.querySelector('input[type="checkbox"]').addEventListener("change", event => {
this.checkboxChange(event.target);
}, false);
} else {
cookMode.style.display = "none";
}
}
}
},
checkboxChange(checkbox) {
if (checkbox.checked) {
this.lock();
} else {
this.unlock();
}
},
setCheckboxesState(state) {
const checkboxes = document.querySelectorAll(this.cookModeSelector + ' input[type="checkbox"]');
for (const checkbox of checkboxes) {
checkbox.checked = state;
}
},
async lock() {
try {
this.wakeLock = await this.wakeLockApi.request("screen");
this.wakeLock.addEventListener("release", () => {
this.wakeLock = false;
this.setCheckboxesState(false);
});
this.setCheckboxesState(true);
} catch (error) {
this.setCheckboxesState(false);
}
},
unlock() {
if (this.wakeLock) {
this.wakeLock.release();
this.wakeLock = false;
}
this.setCheckboxesState(false);
}
}; (function(callback) {
if (document.readyState !== "loading") {
callback();
} else {
document.addEventListener("DOMContentLoaded", callback);
}
})(() => {
window.TastyRecipes.cookMode.init();
}); window.TastyRecipes = window.TastyRecipes || {}; window.TastyRecipes.staticTooltip = {
element: null,
tooltipElement: null,
deleting: false,
init( element ) {
if ( this.deleting ) {
return;
}
this.element = element;
this.buildElements();
},
destroy() {
if ( ! this.tooltipElement || this.deleting ) {
return;
} this.deleting = true;
this.tooltipElement.classList.remove( 'opened' ); setTimeout( () => {
this.tooltipElement.remove();
this.deleting = false;
}, 500 );
},
buildElements() {
const tooltipElement = document.createElement( 'div' );
tooltipElement.classList.add( 'tasty-recipes-static-tooltip');
tooltipElement.setAttribute( 'id', 'tasty-recipes-tooltip' ); const currentTooltipElement = document.getElementById( 'tasty-recipes-tooltip' );
if ( currentTooltipElement ) {
document.body.replaceChild( tooltipElement, currentTooltipElement );
} else {
document.body.appendChild( tooltipElement );
} this.tooltipElement = document.getElementById( 'tasty-recipes-tooltip' );
},
show() {
if ( ! this.tooltipElement ) {
return;
} const tooltipTop = this.element.getBoundingClientRect().top
+ window.scrollY
- 10 // 10px offset.
- this.tooltipElement.getBoundingClientRect().height;
const tooltipLeft = this.element.getBoundingClientRect().left
- ( this.tooltipElement.getBoundingClientRect().width / 2 )
+ ( this.element.getBoundingClientRect().width / 2 ) - 1;
const posLeft = Math.max( 10, tooltipLeft );
this.maybeRemoveTail( posLeft !== tooltipLeft ); this.tooltipElement.setAttribute( 'style', 'top:' + tooltipTop + 'px;left:' + posLeft + 'px;' );
this.tooltipElement.classList.add( 'opened' ); },
maybeRemoveTail( removeTail ) {
if ( removeTail ) {
this.tooltipElement.classList.add( 'tr-hide-tail' );
} else {
this.tooltipElement.classList.remove( 'tr-hide-tail' );
}
},
changeMessage( message ) {
if ( ! this.tooltipElement ) {
return;
}
this.tooltipElement.innerHTML = message;
}
}; window.TastyRecipes.ajax = {
sendPostRequest( url, data, success, failure ) {
const xhr = new XMLHttpRequest();
xhr.open( 'POST', url, true );
xhr.send( this.preparePostData( data ) ); xhr.onreadystatechange = () => {
if ( 4 !== xhr.readyState ) {
return;
}
if ( xhr.status === 200 ) {
success( JSON.parse( xhr.responseText ) );
return;
} failure( xhr );
}; xhr.onerror = () => {
failure( xhr );
};
},
preparePostData( data ) {
const formData = new FormData(); for ( const key in data ) {
formData.append( key, data[key] );
}
return formData;
},
}; window.TastyRecipes.ratings = {
defaultRating: 0,
currentRatingPercentage: 100,
savingRating: false,
init( minRating ) {
this.minRating = minRating; this.formWatchRating();
this.closeTooltipWhenClickOutside();
this.addBodyClassBasedOnSelectedRating();
this.backwardCompFormRatingPosition();
},
formWatchRating() {
const ratings = document.querySelectorAll('.tasty-recipes-no-ratings-buttons [data-rating]');
if ( ratings.length {
event.preventDefault();
this.defaultRating = event.target.closest( '.checked' ).dataset.rating;
this.setCheckedStar( event.target );
this.maybeSendRating( this.defaultRating, event.target );
this.setRatingInForm( this.defaultRating );
} );
}
},
closeTooltipWhenClickOutside() {
window.addEventListener( 'click', e => {
// Bailout (don't remove the tooltip) when the clicked element is a rating star, or it's the tooltip itself.
if ( e.target.closest( '.tasty-recipes-rating' ) || e.target.classList.contains( 'tasty-recipes-static-tooltip' ) ) {
return;
} window.TastyRecipes.staticTooltip.destroy();
} );
},
setRatingInForm( rating ) {
const ratingInput = document.querySelector( '#respond .tasty-recipes-rating[value="' + rating + '"]' );
if ( ! ratingInput ) {
return;
}
ratingInput.click();
},
addBodyClassBasedOnSelectedRating() {
const ratingInputs = document.querySelectorAll( 'input.tasty-recipes-rating' );
if ( ! ratingInputs ) {
return;
}
for ( const ratingInput of ratingInputs ) {
ratingInput.addEventListener( 'click', currentEvent => {
const selectedRating = currentEvent.target.getAttribute( 'value' );
this.handleBodyClassByRating( selectedRating );
this.toggleCommentTextareaRequired( selectedRating );
} );
}
},
handleBodyClassByRating( rating ) {
if ( rating < this.minRating ) {
document.body.classList.remove( 'tasty-recipes-selected-minimum-rating' );
return;
}
document.body.classList.add( 'tasty-recipes-selected-minimum-rating' );
},
toggleCommentTextareaRequired( rating ) {
const commentTextarea = document.getElementById( 'comment' );
if ( ! commentTextarea ) {
return;
} if ( rating {
window.TastyRecipes.staticTooltip.changeMessage( response.data.message );
window.TastyRecipes.staticTooltip.show();
this.updateAverageText( response.data, recipeCardElement );
this.maybeFillCommentForm( response.data ); // Hide the tooltip after 5 seconds.
setTimeout( () => {
this.maybeResetTooltip( recipeCardElement, response.data, rating );
}, 5000 );
},
() => {
this.resetTooltip( recipeCardElement );
}
);
},
updateAverageText( data, recipeCardElement ) {
if ( ! data.average ) {
return;
}
this.setRatingPercent( data ); if ( ! data.count ) {
return;
} const quickLink = document.querySelector( '.tasty-recipes-rating-link' );
if ( quickLink ) {
this.setTextInContainer( quickLink, data );
this.setPartialStar( quickLink );
} const cardStars = recipeCardElement.querySelector( '.tasty-recipes-ratings-buttons' );
cardStars.dataset.trDefaultRating = data.average;
this.setTextInContainer( recipeCardElement.querySelector( '.tasty-recipes-rating' ), data );
},
setTextInContainer( container, data ) {
if ( ! container ) {
return;
} if ( data.label ) {
const ratingLabelElement = container.querySelector( '.rating-label' );
if ( ratingLabelElement ) {
ratingLabelElement.innerHTML = data.label;
}
return;
} const averageElement = container.querySelector( '.average' );
if ( averageElement ) {
averageElement.textContent = data.average;
} const countElement = container.querySelector( '.count' );
if ( countElement ) {
countElement.textContent = data.count;
}
},
setPartialStar( container ) {
const highestStar = container.querySelector( '[data-rating="' + Math.ceil( this.defaultRating ) + '"]' );
if ( highestStar ) {
highestStar.dataset.trClip = this.currentRatingPercentage;
}
},
setRatingPercent( data ) {
this.defaultRating = data.average.toFixed( 1 );
const parts = data.average.toFixed( 2 ).toString().split( '.' );
this.currentRatingPercentage = parts[1] ? parts[1] : 100;
if ( this.currentRatingPercentage === '00' ) {
this.currentRatingPercentage = 100;
}
},
setCheckedStar( target ) {
const cardRatingContainer = target.closest( '.tasty-recipes-ratings-buttons' );
const selectedRatingElement = cardRatingContainer.querySelector( '[data-tr-checked]' );
if ( selectedRatingElement ) {
delete selectedRatingElement.dataset.trChecked;
} const thisStar = target.closest( '.tasty-recipes-rating' );
thisStar.dataset.trChecked = 1;
thisStar.querySelector( '[data-tr-clip]' ).dataset.trClip = 100;
},
maybeFillCommentForm( data ) {
if ( ! data.comment || ! data.comment.content ) {
return;
} const commentForm = document.querySelector( '#commentform' );
if ( ! commentForm ) {
return;
} const commentBox = commentForm.querySelector( '[name=comment]' );
if ( ! commentBox || commentBox.value ) {
return;
} // Add comment details for editing.
commentBox.innerHTML = data.comment.content;
if ( data.comment.name ) {
commentForm.querySelector( '[name=author]' ).value = data.comment.name;
commentForm.querySelector( '[name=email]' ).value = data.comment.email;
}
},
maybeResetTooltip( recipeCardElement, data, rating ) {
if ( this.savingRating === rating ) {
this.resetTooltip( recipeCardElement, data );
}
},
resetTooltip( recipeCardElement, data ) {
window.TastyRecipes.staticTooltip.destroy();
this.savingRating = false; // Reset the default rating.
const cardRatingContainer = recipeCardElement.querySelector( '.tasty-recipes-ratings-buttons' );
if ( cardRatingContainer ) {
this.defaultRating = ( data && data.average ) ? data.average.toFixed(1) : cardRatingContainer.dataset.trDefaultRating;
cardRatingContainer.dataset.trDefaultRating = this.defaultRating; this.resetSelectedStar( cardRatingContainer, data );
}
},
resetSelectedStar( cardRatingContainer ) {
const selectedRatingElement = cardRatingContainer.querySelector( '[data-rating="' + Math.ceil( this.defaultRating ) + '"]' );
if ( selectedRatingElement ) {
selectedRatingElement.querySelector( '[data-tr-clip]' ).dataset.trClip = this.currentRatingPercentage;
selectedRatingElement.parentNode.dataset.trChecked = 1;
} const previousSelectedElement= cardRatingContainer.querySelector( '[data-tr-checked]' );
if ( previousSelectedElement ) {
const currentSelectedRating = previousSelectedElement.querySelector('[data-rating]');
if ( currentSelectedRating !== selectedRatingElement ) {
delete previousSelectedElement.dataset.trChecked;
}
}
},
backwardCompFormRatingPosition() {
const ratingsButtons = document.querySelector( '#respond .tasty-recipes-ratings-buttons, #tasty-recipes-comment-rating .tasty-recipes-ratings-buttons' );
if ( ! ratingsButtons ) {
return;
}
const ratingsButtonsStyles = window.getComputedStyle(ratingsButtons);
if ( ! ratingsButtonsStyles.display.includes( 'flex' ) ) {
ratingsButtons.style.direction = 'rtl';
} if ( typeof tastyRecipesRating !== 'undefined' ) {
// Select the rating that was previously selected in admin.
ratingsButtons.querySelector( '.tasty-recipes-rating[value="' + tastyRecipesRating + '"]' ).checked = true;
} const ratingSpans = ratingsButtons.querySelectorAll( '.tasty-recipes-rating' );
for (const ratingSpan of ratingSpans) {
ratingSpan.addEventListener( 'click', event => {
if ( ratingSpan === event.target ) {
return;
}
ratingSpan.previousElementSibling.click();
} );
}
}
}; (function(callback) {
if (document.readyState !== "loading") {
callback();
} else {
window.addEventListener( 'load', callback );
}
})(() => {
window.TastyRecipes.ratings.init( window.trCommon ? window.trCommon.minRating : 4 );
});
Loading...